Illustration
The same couple, two agents, one sale
Illustration: a couple view a house with Agent A in spring but don't make an offer. The seller later switches to Agent B. In the autumn, the couple see the new listing, view again with Agent B and buy.
Agent B expects its fee for the sale it negotiated. Agent A points to a clause entitling it to commission if a buyer it introduced buys within a stated period after the instruction ended. If both clauses apply, the seller faces two fees. Had the seller passed Agent A's introduced-buyer list to Agent B, the risk could have been raised before an offer was accepted.
The charges that can follow you
| Charge | What usually triggers it | Ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Introduced-buyer commission | A buyer the first agent introduced later buys | The clause, the time limit and the buyer's name |
| Withdrawal charge | Ending the instruction, especially early | The clause and how the figure was set |
| Marketing costs | Leaving before a stated point | An itemised breakdown |
| Ready, willing and able fee | A qualifying buyer was introduced before you withdrew | The definition in your terms |
How a two-fee claim arises
Each agency agreement is a separate contract. The second agent has no automatic knowledge of the first agent's terms, and neither agreement cancels the other. If both say a fee is payable for the same buyer, both agents may claim.
Agents who are members of The Property Ombudsman must point out in their terms that you could be liable for two fees if you instruct another agent without ending the first agreement properly, or if a buyer introduced by one agent buys through another. That warning exists because the situation does happen.
Reducing the risk before it starts
- End the first instruction properly, in writing, before the second agent markets your home.
- Ask the first agent for its list of introduced buyers and the period its claim lasts.
- Give that list to the second agent and ask it to flag any returning buyer before an offer is accepted.
- Ask the second agent, in writing, how it would handle a buyer who appears on the first agent's list.
If you receive an invoice you don't agree with
Don't ignore it and don't pay immediately. Ask the agent to identify the clause it relies on and to explain how the buyer was introduced, with dates. Compare that with your own records.
If you still disagree, use the agent's complaints procedure. Estate agents in England must belong to an approved redress scheme, which you can approach once the complaints procedure is exhausted. For larger sums, or where both agents are claiming, qualified legal advice may be worthwhile.
Keep in mind
A claim isn't proof of a debt
Neither is a missing clause proof that nothing is owed. The wording and the facts decide, and both can be checked.
Find the fee terms that can outlast the instruction
Tick each one as you find it. Nothing is saved or sent, and ticking doesn't check the clause.
0 of 4 ticked
Frequently asked questions
How long after I leave can an agent claim commission?
It depends on the agreement. Many state a period after the instruction ends during which an introduced buyer can still trigger a fee.
Does it count as an introduction if the buyer only saw the online listing?
That depends on how your agreement defines an introduction. Some definitions are broad, so check the exact wording.
Can the two agents sort it out between themselves?
Sometimes agents agree to share a fee, but they don't have to. Raise it before accepting an offer, while there is still room to agree.
Is a withdrawal charge always enforceable?
No charge is automatically enforceable or automatically void. Whether it can be relied on depends on the wording, how clearly it was explained and the circumstances.
Will the redress scheme decide the fee for me?
A redress scheme can consider complaints about an agent's conduct and may award redress. It isn't a court, and it has its own rules about what it can look at.
What to do next
- 1Find the introduced-buyer and withdrawal clauses in your first agreement.
- 2Get the first agent's buyer list and share it with your new agent.
- 3Flag any returning buyer to both agents in writing before accepting an offer.
- 4If invoiced, ask for the clause and dates, then use the complaints procedure if you disagree.
